Name: Bellisario Pizza Shop
Price range: $$

Bellisario Pizza Shop Information

Located in the heart of West Mifflin, PA, Bellisario Pizza Shop is a cozy local gem that has garnered a loyal following for its mouthwatering pizza and warm, welcoming atmosphere. Just off Homeville Rd, this unassuming spot might seem simple at first glance, but step inside, and you're greeted with the delicious aromas of freshly baked pizza dough, bubbling cheese, and the sizzling sounds of a true pizzeria in action.

The menu at Bellisario is a perfect balance of classic and creative options. Of course, their signature pizza is the highlight, with a crispy, yet tender crust that supports a generous layer of toppings. From the traditional pepperoni and sausage to the more inventive specialty pies like the white pizza with garlic and spinach, there’s something for everyone. The sauce, tangy and slightly sweet, complements the high-quality mozzarella that’s melted to perfection every time.

But it’s not just the pizza that makes this place stand out. The shop also serves a variety of pasta dishes that feel like they’ve been passed down through generations. The spaghetti with marinara sauce is simple yet packed with flavor, while the baked ziti comes smothered in a rich, cheesy sauce that makes every bite indulgent. The salads are fresh and vibrant, offering a nice counterbalance to the heavier main courses.

Service here is friendly and attentive. The staff seems genuinely happy to help, and they know their menu inside and out, offering suggestions to suit any craving. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, you’ll be treated with the same care and attention, which adds to the overall sense of community that defines Bellisario Pizza Shop.

The atmosphere is relaxed, making it an ideal spot for a casual meal with friends or family. It’s not the kind of place that’s flashy or trendy, but it has a comforting, homey feel that keeps diners coming back. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely dinner, the warm service and satisfying food make it an experience worth repeating.

Bellisario Pizza Shop’s affordability is another reason it stands out in a town full of dining options. For a reasonable price, you can enjoy a hearty meal that doesn’t sacrifice flavor or quality. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pizza night or want to try something new, this spot is well worth the visit. If you find yourself in West Mifflin, be sure to stop by and enjoy a slice of local pizza perfection.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

I love neighborhood pizza joints and this place nails it. Fresh, friendly and delicious. CASH ONLY but they do have an ATM inside ($2 fee). Had a large pepperoni and bread sticks. Both were awesome, and I will be back next time I'm near Kennywood (8 minutes away).

I Actually stumbled upon this place accident. It was the day before Christmas Eve And the only place That was open within A 40 minute drive. The owner was concerned about making my pizza fresh, even though I had to be his last Customer of the night. I’m a small girl, but there were only two slices left of that medium pepperoni pizza by the time I got home. Perfect, thin crunchy crust And their sauce had a slight kick to it, but I wouldn’t consider it spicy Or too hot. I don’t know, but it was really good and I’ve been thinking about it for Days.

Called late for take out. They were closing, but still had the decency to take my order. First time eating there, got a steak roll. Food was fresh and tasted fantastic. Will definitely be ordering there again. Thanks guys!

Drove 25 minutes out of my way to give it a try and it was worth every second! Seriously one of the best pizza’s I’ve had in a very long time! 10/10

Really good pizza, great owner. Try it out you won't be disappointed.

Surprisingly good pizza! The location looks dated (they’ve been open since 1978, and it shows), but the owner, Mundo, struck up a conversation with us while we were waiting for our pizza to finish cooking (we were early). When we got home, the pizzas were still hot. The sauce is the real treat here. It’s sweet but not too much so, and it has a definite baked flavor like it’s been slow-cooked on the stove for a while. I love that slightly burnt taste, and it really makes for a pleasantly sweet, smokiness to the sauce. There were plenty of toppings, but I’m a cheese man and could have had more on my pies. The price was reasonable, so I’m sure I’ll be ordering pizza from here again.

Legit one of my favorites!! A hidden gem we stumbled across!! Try the pan pizza won’t regret it

BEST PIZZA! We always order a traditional pie and a white pizza and it’s cooked to perfection and dough-licious EVERY time. It’s a small family-owned business that treats their customers well and definitely keeps us coming back.

Bellisario Pizza Shop